• Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won


calawyer last won the day on January 10

calawyer had the most liked content!

Community Reputation

1,839 Excellent

About calawyer

  • Rank
    I do not endorse any of the ads appearing in my posts.

Profile Fields

  • Location

Recent Profile Visitors

7,163 profile views
  1. Sorry I have been AWOL lately. I won't bore you with the details. Lack of service is an excellent ground to seek relief from default. It is possible, but hard, to do it yourself. I would really recommend that you speak with an attorney like Ian Chowdhury (, to see if you could retain him at least for the purpose of getting the default set aside.
  2. Can you send again. I didn't get the pm.
  3. I don't see anything about a settlement conference. Maybe Plaintiff messed up. But you have to go anyway for the trial readiness conference so that rule of court is good to know. You should check out the form they want you to fill out and post any questions you may have.
  4. On the front of their Statement, they list November 9 at 9:30 in Dept C-66 as the date, time, and Dept of the Settlement Conference. So THEY think there is one scheduled on that date. In the local rules for trial readiness conference, do they say that there will be a settlement conference? In any event, you should attend. If you want to do a brief statement of your own, you should point out that ALL issues are disputed. THey say "none" but when you file a general denial, that puts everything in the complaint at issue. And you dispute the assignment and the amount owed.
  5. On the front page of the Mandatory Settlement Conference Statement, did they list a date, time and Dept??
  6. Check the online docket to see if the Court has calendared a settlement conference. You should also check the local rules to see if the Court sets one in EVERY case. Also, did plaintiff list a date, time, and Dept on the caption page?
  7. So happy for you. And so amazed that a Hospital would not be aware of the leading California case on this issue. Maybe I am naïve. Maybe they wanted to see if you knew the law. If so, shame on them. Again, nice going!
  8. I think you meant to post this in another thread.
  9. calawyer

    Proof of Service for BOP

    Responding to your post as well. A BOP entitles you to "a copy of the account". I usually ask for the assignment and any contract as well. I don't want to say this on the forum, but we are not entitled to the assignment or contract under CCP 454. JDBs either don't know the rule or haven't read it in a long time and usually give us the assignment and contract too. But I wouldn't ask for more than that. If you want further documents, we can do an RFP later. Send the original signed BOP to plaintiff. The correct way to do it is to send a proof to plaintiff all filled out but unsigned (you are supposed to sign it AFTER you have sealed the envelope and mailed it). I will tell you, however, that no one does it correctly. THey send a copy of the signed proof instead.
  10. calawyer

    Cause of Action

    Let's hereby change our BOP to read as follows: "...setting forth the items and details of the account on which plaintiff's complaint is based..." No need to flag any cause of action that permits a BOP. Just makes it easier for them to object.
  11. As to dismissed or stayed, I think staying it is contemplated by CCP § 1281.4. If Plaintiff doesn't respond by the time of the hearing, tell the court that you sent it to plaintiff on ____ for approval as to form and have not heard back. The Judge will probably ask you to do it again.
  12. The reports are very useful and I applaud JAMS for being so transparent. Something everyone should check when evaluating an arbitrator. I have them saved on my system. I have also seen rulings that agreeing to the JAMS rules, trumps the language in the contract and also California law. I have also seen rulings the other way. Just an issue that one should consider especially if there is no right to appeal.
  13. The OP said that the AGREEMENT provided that the losing party must pay all arbitration costs and fees. That would be a valid reason, in my opinion, not to elect arbitration if I believed that the arbitration forum would uphold it under Civil Code section 1717 (although this section makes any such obligation reciprocal so that should be considered if you have a good case). JAMS is not the only arbitration forum and all have their own rules which should be checked. While it may be true that some attorneys are not experienced in arbitration, most CONSUMER attorneys (i.e. NACA members) are. They have to be in a post Concepcion world where most consumer contracts are presented on a "take it or leave it" basis and contain arbitration clauses and class action waivers. You should ask any attorney you are considering whether he or she has experience in arbitration.
  14. Generally, a demurrer in collection cases (as well as in most "run of the mill lawsuits" ) is not a great strategy decision. Here is why: In collection actions, most Plaintiffs use the judicial council form complaint. It is an uphill climb to contend that a bunch of judges got together to draft a form that somehow does not contain all of the essential elements of a cause of action. Sometimes, there will be an element missing from a complaint and a demurrer will be appropriate. But the court will grant leave to amend if your demurrer is sustained. So you must ask yourself, "can plaintiff amend"? If so, all you have done is spin your wheels and you have educated your opponent as to a part of its case of which it had not been aware. If, however, the plaintiff cannot amend, a demurrer might be appropriate. One example might be where the complaint on its face shows that it is barred by the SOL. In that situation, plaintiff can't fix the problem and it may be worth the effort.
  15. You might want to prepare a proposed order compelling arbitration. Submit it to Plaintiff for approval as to form and walk it to the hearing to give to the judge. If you want to post something here or by PM, I will take a look at it. Simple order: You filed the motion on ___ Plaintiff didn't oppose Court orders that this case be stayed and the matter submitted for arbitration at _______.