Cat123

Members
  • Content Count

    87
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Community Reputation

11 Good

About Cat123

  • Rank
    CIC Member

Profile Fields

  • Location
    Florida
  1. I just don't know where to go from here. We've been dealing with this since 2010. Fell in to arrears, Indy Mac to One West/Deutsch Bank, to Ocwen. Hired an atty. but time and time again, doing absolutely everything all servicers told us to do, we still couldn't get a completed package to them. We were unprepared at court as to what would happen and accepted a judgement of $679K. IN THE MEANTIME, we were able to reduce all debt and/or pay off and our 2nd mortgage was dismissed by SunTrust. We then had to file Chapter 13 to get a stay and the sale date was cancelled. We were granted a court ordered mediation and again, several packages and the same info to the lender, through our attorney. In the meantime, we were subjected to a Federal Bankruptcy Audit (Holy moly), because our case, and numbers, threw up a red flag. We came through that just fine. Not fun, but AOK. Then, we were denied a modification based on income. They used only my husband's SS income, and not mine, which is about $150K/ year. We applied for an appeal and rec'd a notice they had received the appeal on October 6, and on October 12th, Columbus Day, they sent us a letter of denial based on the same figures they had before, which are totally out of whack, showing a DTI of 201%. We have been making our Chapter 13 payments on time and with no problem. Our principle has now increased from $679K to $723K, and the numbers on the judgement, we have found, do not include credits for taxes paid. Is there anything we have left to fight with? It just seems they have never acted in good faith... at all. The ONLY reason to stay with Chapter 13 is to make the arrears payments over 5 years. Thank you.
  2. I got what I wanted and won my MTC arb with Cap One. Atty was so ill-prepared. The 2008 agreement was the show stopper, although they tried the 2010, and Ross vs BOA didn't come in to it. Now what do I do? I don't know that they did anything wrong. I wanted to buy some time until deciding for sure on Chapter 13. I suppose I just start at page one... but is there is a list of what could be violations? I saw a few things, as I recall, posted by Linda7. So.... what if I decided not to go to arbitration? I have to initiate withing 30 days and then case will be dismissed. I wonder if they will talk to me about settling? Can I decide to go the court route or ?????? I'm in a pickle. The judge was very nice, I thought. He said, "Do you know what you're getting into? It could be much more onerous. It's not a magic bullet." By the way, it took them 8 months to respond to my MTC, and another 4 to get to court. Thanks for anything and everything.
  3. Do you happen to have a Cap One arbitration agreeement? Multi-years a real plus. Thanks so much.
  4. If one owes the debt, tried to settle but OC attorney renegged, and now going to Arbitration, what should I be expecting to happen tomorrow? I can't rely on the violations as the OC atty./debt collector is a separate entity and it appears that has no relevance in Arbitration. I would just like to be somewhat prepared for what will probably happen. Anything will help. Anyone?
  5. Now I have no clue as to what to do... I just rec'd an Arbitration brief from the atty for the OC. First, there is a different court named. (different county) 1. But in the brief, they state that all our statements in regard to violations have nothing to do with the creditor as they are not subject to the fair debt, etc. rules. They state "XXXXX" is a creditor whose main business is banking and finance. "Since they are the creditor, FDCPA rules do not apply when they are collecting their own debt." 2. They state that our claims re: FCRA aren't any good as they did not receive a notice of dispute from a credit reporting agency. 3. They state there is no "Florida Consumer Protection" law. They also re-state breach of contract, unjust enrichment and account stated. What this whole thing comes down to is that we had to try to work things out with all our creditors, which we did, except for them... so far. We all agreed to a settlement, but they wouldn't put it in writing in the correct form. They basically wanted us to send them a check with no agreement that it was the final amount. We tried and tried, and one office would tell us one thing and another office would tell us another. I truly do not know what to do.... at all. We just rec'd the "respondent's brief" and arbitration is tomorrow. They also included an affidavit from the Lead Litigation Specialist for the servicing company who stated the billing/statements are correct. Ugh. Hope someone can give me some words of wisdom to get through this. Not looking good, is it? I just don't know where to go with this. Thank you.
  6. Now I have no clue as to what to do... I just rec'd an Arbitration brief from the atty for the OC. First, there is a different court named. (different county) 1. But in the brief, they state that all our statements in regard to violations have nothing to do with the creditor as they are not subject to the fair debt, etc. rules. They state "XXXXX" is a creditor whose main business is banking and finance. "Since they are the creditor, FDCPA rules do not apply when they are collecting their own debt." 2. They state that our claims un FCRA aren't any good as they did not receive a notice of dispute from a credit reporting agency. 3. They state there is no "Florida Consumer Protection" law. They also re-state breach of contract, unjust enrichment and account stated. What this whole thing comes down to is that we had to try to work things out with all our creditors, which we did, except for them... so far. We all agreed to a settlement, but they wouldn't put it in writing in the correct form. They basically wanted us to send them a check with no agreement that it was the final amount. We tried and tried, and one office would tell us one thing and another office would tell us another. I truly do not know what to do.... at all. We just rec'd the "respondent's brief" and arbitration is tomorrow. They also included an affidavit from the Lead Litigation Specialist for the servicing company who stated the billing/statements are correct. Ugh. Hope someone can give me some words of wisdom to get through this. Not looking good, is it? Thank you.
  7. You all are wonderful. Thank you again, and again.... and I'll let you know how it all comes out. Sure got one heck of an education. This time last year, I would have thought a MTC was a just a friendly hand wave.
  8. So..... Now we are waiting for the upcoming arbitration meeting. We were going to be in that area, so we played nice, nice... and agreed to meet 2 hours away from us. Also 2 hours away for the Judge. Then, the atty. said their office is "not available" and we need to decide on another. We chose to go to the JAMS office, which is 5 hrs. away for atty. We have now been notified that a telephone arb could take place if all agree. I don't think that's a good idea. Suggestions? Strategy? Thank you!
  9. So..... Now we are waiting for the upcoming arbitration meeting. We were going to be in that area, so we played nice, nice and agreed to meet 2 hours away from us. Also 2 hours away for the Judge. Then, the atty. said their office is "not available" and we need to decide on another. We chose to go to the JAMS office, 5 hrs. away for atty. We have now been notified that a telephone arb could take place if all agree. I don't think that's a good idea. Suggestions? Strategy? Thank you!
  10. Good to know! I don't know how I could have made it through the last year without this board. Just amazing, amazing people every where I turn.
  11. Yes, everything I send is certified.... and I did it multiple times, to which they never responded until arb commenced, over one year. Thanks much. I'll let everyone know how it goes!
  12. All that matters for the lawsuit is if they can prove they are a real party in interest. The name on the complaint has to match whatever proof they submit. I haven't seen anything showing exactly that, other than their letters stating they have been retained, and Discover charged it off 12/11, and then the law firm started in.
  13. Just curious.... Being sued by Discover Card, that's what it says on the statement, too. But, my credit report states Discover Financial Services, LLC, with all numbers matching the complaint. Is the wrong entity named in the suit? Thank you.
  14. How did you dispute, and what did you say you were disputing? Req'd DV disputing the alledged amount And it's a law firm with the OC as Plaintiff.