Mancuso_212 Posted April 30 Report Posted April 30 Good evening all, Like most of us here, need some help and want to go about this the best way. For privacy, I am going to speak with as little information as possible just in-case of anything. There are a lot of different parts to this so would appreciate any help. The overall total is 14k. This is from a supposed Lending Club debt owned by Velocity. As of today, Velocity Investments is suing, served today. I will absolutely respond. My question is i'm not sure how to go about this. I've called a couple of lawyer for "Free consultations" and they all want to obviously be hired but didn't really get much info. From my own knowledge and searching, it looks like they have violated at least three FDCPA violations - not them directly but their collectors before the lawyer. Based on from what I see, arbitration is the way to go but not sure how to go about it. Can I use the court provided answer form and add in the MTC ? Chat GPT created an answer for me but it’s 4 pages long. Any help would be greatly appreciated. I want to get this done safely and hopefully fast. It should be noted that I also don't have any personal income or assets and live in NYC. Thank you. Quote
nobk4me Posted May 2 Report Posted May 2 Yes, arbitration is the best way to go. I have no knowledge of New York procedures. Quote
LaneBlane Posted May 2 Report Posted May 2 I recently helped a friend win in arbitration on a WebBank/LendingClub case. The documents in your case may be similar. I have a few questions: Do your documents include a Borrower Agreement with an attached Exhibit A (Promissory Note)? If so, does the Promissory Note include blank lines instead of information on the amount owed, interest, terms, etc? Does the end of the Promissory Note include text that says it was signed electronically on your behalf? Have they provided any additional promissory notes? Does the top edge of your Borrower Agreement (first page and possibly other pages) include an account or loan number? If so, does the account or loan number match yours? Quote
BV80 Posted May 2 Report Posted May 2 On 4/29/2026 at 11:06 PM, Mancuso_212 said: From my own knowledge and searching, it looks like they have violated at least three FDCPA violations - not them directly but their collectors before the lawyer. How did the collection agency violate the FDCPA? When did the violations occur? Quote
Mancuso_212 Posted May 2 Author Report Posted May 2 5 hours ago, LaneBlane said: I recently helped a friend win in arbitration on a WebBank/LendingClub case. The documents in your case may be similar. I have a few questions: Do your documents include a Borrower Agreement with an attached Exhibit A (Promissory Note)? If so, does the Promissory Note include blank lines instead of information on the amount owed, interest, terms, etc? Does the end of the Promissory Note include text that says it was signed electronically on your behalf? Have they provided any additional promissory notes? Does the top edge of your Borrower Agreement (first page and possibly other pages) include an account or loan number? If so, does the account or loan number match yours? Hello. Yes, the summons and complaint has a blank Exhibit A attached to it and also states signed electronically. Earlier in the year, I submitted a DV and the promissory note I received then has numbers typed in. All the pages have a loan number and it is redacted except for the last four - I have to confirm if those are correct. Something else I noticed, my loan summary has a principal balance of $0 and also a payoff balance of $0 as of 2/4/25. They bought the loan 1/25/25. Quote
Mancuso_212 Posted May 3 Author Report Posted May 3 33 minutes ago, BV80 said: How did the collection agency violate the FDCPA? When did the violations occur? The violations occurred last year. First, the letter one of the collectors sent states “due date above” but the dates due are on the right. The above date was the date of the letter and is earlier which is confusing. We also spoke in May but the letter was sent in August, not within 5 days. When I tried to DV electronically with the law firm, it failed and did not go through. There was also a phone call to my parents house and spouse’s job. Lastly, Velocity or Lending Club never sent a letter introducing themselves or stating the debt was sold. Minimal charges but valid, no ? Quote
BV80 Posted May 3 Report Posted May 3 11 hours ago, Mancuso_212 said: The violations occurred last year. First, the letter one of the collectors sent states “due date above” but the dates due are on the right. The above date was the date of the letter and is earlier which is confusing. We also spoke in May but the letter was sent in August, not within 5 days. In my opinion, a date being listed on the side instead of “above” is not going to be considered significant. You figured it out, so it would be argued that it wasn’t confusing enough to prevent you from making a decision and didn’t cause you to make any mistakes (such as a late or missed payment). In regard to their failure to send the letter within 5 days, that would be your word against theirs. As long as they can show it’s their normal practice to send notices within 5 days of an initial communication, there will be no violation. 11 hours ago, Mancuso_212 said: When I tried to DV electronically with the law firm, it failed and did not go through. That’s not a violation. It was a computer error. As long as they have a physical address that is available for consumers’ communications, it would hard to show that the computer glitch or failure prevented you from requesting validation. Also, did you send a DV request within 30 days of receiving the collection letter that contained the 30-day notice? 11 hours ago, Mancuso_212 said: There was also a phone call to my parents house and spouse’s job. From 15 U.S. Code § 1692c(d) of the FDCPA. (d) Consumer” defined For the purpose of this section, the term “consumer” includes the consumer’s spouse, parent (if the consumer is a minor), guardian, executor, or administrator. The FDCPA specifies that if you’re married, a debt collector can contact your spouse. Was the debt collector informed not to call you or your spouse at work? If not, no violation. in regard to your parents, what was said by the debt collector? Did the collector reveal that you owe a debt? Did your parents record the call? 11 hours ago, Mancuso_212 said: Lastly, Velocity or Lending Club never sent a letter introducing themselves or stating the debt was sold. There is no section of the FDCPA that I know of that required a debt collector to introduce itself or to inform a consumer that it purchased the consumer’s defaulted account. Collection agencies and debt buyers are not required to collect a debt a if they choose not to do so. In the event a debt buyer attempts to collect a debt, its initial communication letter should include the name of the original creditor and the current owner of the account. That would be the introduction. Anything the original creditor was required to do but failed to do would not be covered by the FDCPA because that Act does, to apply to original creditors. Just remember that, in court, just as a debt collector must prove any allegations they make against you, you must prove any allegation you make against the debt collector. For instance, if you allege that the debt collector failed to send an initial communication within 5 days of talking to you, how do you prove it? You must also prove that a certain action is required or prohibited by the FDCPA. If you allege that debt buyer is required to send a letter specifically to inform you that it purchased your account, you have to provide that statute or court precedent that makes that requirement. 1 Quote
BV80 Posted May 3 Report Posted May 3 @Mancuso_212 Also, you said the violations occurred last year. There’s a one year SOL for FDCPA violations. It starts the date the alleged violation occurs. Quote
LaneBlane Posted May 4 Report Posted May 4 On 5/2/2026 at 6:54 PM, Mancuso_212 said: Hello. Yes, the summons and complaint has a blank Exhibit A attached to it and also states signed electronically. Earlier in the year, I submitted a DV and the promissory note I received then has numbers typed in. If you received a Truth in Lending statement, I would check these numbers against it. On 5/2/2026 at 6:54 PM, Mancuso_212 said: All the pages have a loan number and it is redacted except for the last four - I have to confirm if those are correct. You should definitely check the last four digits of the loan number against the loan number on their collection notices. On 5/2/2026 at 6:54 PM, Mancuso_212 said: Something else I noticed, my loan summary has a principal balance of $0 and also a payoff balance of $0 as of 2/4/25. They bought the loan 1/25/25. This is interesting. My friend's Loan Summary didn't have a zeroed out Principal Balance or Payoff Balance. Does the Loan ID number at the top of the summary match the last four digits that appear at the top of your loan documents? Also, if the summary includes a list of documents, is the promissory note with information filled out included on this list? Quote
Mancuso_212 Posted May 4 Author Report Posted May 4 Don’t know how to respond and quote individually, sorry. I checked the Truth and Lending and the APR on it is different from the promissory note. The one on the statement is correct. The one filled in is lower. The last four digits match collection. The $0 balance is as of 2/4/25. On the bottom of the page, it also states it was created by Lending Club on 2/5/25 but on other documents, Velocity bought it on 1/25/25. For the list of documents, it says promissory note but I don't know if it’s the one thats filled out. Lastly, the last page where Velocity tries to show it purchased it by buying a “lot”. the total balance and unpaid balance is redacted. Also, all the documents have the last four of a “loan id” on the top left but borrower id is redacted everywhere. Quote
Mancuso_212 Posted May 4 Author Report Posted May 4 16 hours ago, BV80 said: In my opinion, a date being listed on the side instead of “above” is not going to be considered significant. You figured it out, so it would be argued that it wasn’t confusing enough to prevent you from making a decision and didn’t cause you to make any mistakes (such as a late or missed payment). I understand this but technically “it can confuse the least sophisticated consumer” but it’s not major, I understand. In regard to their failure to send the letter within 5 days, that would be your word against theirs. As long as they can show it’s their normal practice to send notices within 5 days of an initial communication, there will be no violation. I have a call log from May and the letter dated August. That’s not a violation. It was a computer error. As long as they have a physical address that is available for consumers’ communications, it would hard to show that the computer glitch or failure prevented you from requesting validation. Got it. I was hoping this would have showed a roadblock. Also, did you send a DV request within 30 days of receiving the collection letter that contained the 30-day notice? Yes, I did. From 15 U.S. Code § 1692c(d) of the FDCPA. (d) Consumer” defined For the purpose of this section, the term “consumer” includes the consumer’s spouse, parent (if the consumer is a minor), guardian, executor, or administrator. The FDCPA specifies that if you’re married, a debt collector can contact your spouse. Was the debt collector informed not to call you or your spouse at work? If not, no violation. Yes, the first was and then the 2nd still called. in regard to your parents, what was said by the debt collector? Did the collector reveal that you owe a debt? Did your parents record the call? No recording. There is no section of the FDCPA that I know of that required a debt collector to introduce itself or to inform a consumer that it purchased the consumer’s defaulted account. Collection agencies and debt buyers are not required to collect a debt a if they choose not to do so. In the event a debt buyer attempts to collect a debt, its initial communication letter should include the name of the original creditor and the current owner of the account. That would be the introduction. Anything the original creditor was required to do but failed to do would not be covered by the FDCPA because that Act does, to apply to original creditors. Just remember that, in court, just as a debt collector must prove any allegations they make against you, you must prove any allegation you make against the debt collector. For instance, if you allege that the debt collector failed to send an initial communication within 5 days of talking to you, how do you prove it? Call log and letter. You must also prove that a certain action is required or prohibited by the FDCPA. If you allege that debt buyer is required to send a letter specifically to inform you that it purchased your account, you have to provide that statute or court precedent that makes that requirement. Quote
BV80 Posted May 4 Report Posted May 4 6 hours ago, Mancuso_212 said: In regard to their failure to send the letter within 5 days, that would be your word against theirs. As long as they can show it’s their normal practice to send notices within 5 days of an initial communication, there will be no violation. I have a call log from May and the letter dated August. I understand what you mean. However, this particular requirement is hard for consumers to prove because it’s a “you said/they said” situation. They can claim they sent you a 30-day notice within 5 days of the time you spoke with them. In fact, they can claim they sent it before you spoke to them and that the letter you received in August just contained the same notice. When you spoke with them in May, who initiated that call? Did you call them or did they call you? 6 hours ago, Mancuso_212 said: The FDCPA specifies that if you’re married, a debt collector can contact your spouse. Was the debt collector informed not to call you or your spouse at work? If not, no violation. Yes, the first was and then the 2nd still called. When you say “2nd still called”, do you mean the 2nd debt collector was from a different collection agency than the first caller? Quote
Mancuso_212 Posted May 4 Author Report Posted May 4 1 hour ago, BV80 said: 1 hour ago, BV80 said: When you say “2nd still called”, do you mean the 2nd debt collector was from a different collection agency than the first caller? Yes, the first was a collector and the 2nd was law firm/collector. 1 hour ago, BV80 said: Quote
BV80 Posted May 4 Report Posted May 4 38 minutes ago, Mancuso_212 said: Yes, the first was a collector and the 2nd was law firm/collector. Ok. The 2nd caller was a different collection agency. The 1st collector was told not to call your wife at work. If the 2nd collector was not given the same information, there’s no violation. You’d have to show that it was the responsibility of the 1st collector to inform the 2nd collector of the work call prohibition. If you don’t mind revealing it, who was first caller? Quote
LaneBlane Posted May 4 Report Posted May 4 12 hours ago, Mancuso_212 said: Lastly, the last page where Velocity tries to show it purchased it by buying a “lot”. the total balance and unpaid balance is redacted. Also, all the documents have the last four of a “loan id” on the top left but borrower id is redacted everywhere. When I was helping a friend fight her LendingClub case in arbitration, we discovered they were using contracts and other documents that belonged to the wrong loan number. The last four digits of her Loan ID were redacted on some docs and appeared on others. The numbers that did show were wrong. I found documents in several other court cases in other parts of the country where the same thing had been done. Make a note of all the inconsistencies you find. Quote
Mancuso_212 Posted May 4 Author Report Posted May 4 10 minutes ago, LaneBlane said: When I was helping a friend fight her LendingClub case in arbitration, we discovered they were using contracts and other documents that belonged to the wrong loan number. The last four digits of her Loan ID were redacted on some docs and appeared on others. The numbers that did show were wrong. I found documents in several other court cases in other parts of the country where the same thing had been done. Make a note of all the inconsistencies you find. So the arbitrator would listen to these issues if I were to break them down ? Also, how ? Just basically explain what I am seeing ? Quote
LaneBlane Posted May 4 Report Posted May 4 2 hours ago, Mancuso_212 said: So the arbitrator would listen to these issues if I were to break them down ? It depends on the inconsistencies and whether or not there's an explanation for them. At the very least you can request unredacted documents during discovery to see if they can even produce them. The variance between the Truth in Lending statement and the promissory note sound interesting. Does the completed promissory note include a date or date signed? Quote
Mancuso_212 Posted May 4 Author Report Posted May 4 4 hours ago, LaneBlane said: It depends on the inconsistencies and whether or not there's an explanation for them. At the very least you can request unredacted documents during discovery to see if they can even produce them. The variance between the Truth in Lending statement and the promissory note sound interesting. Does the completed promissory note include a date or date signed? Hi. Almost all of the pages say they are a copy and created on 7/2022 (including the blank one). The completed one says it’s a copy and was created on 8/2022. Truth and lending was created in 2/2025 but again, it shows a $0 balance. Also, there are four pages that show payments and breakdown and these pages don't have a created or copy date. Looks like they were just printed. There is also a page called “Exhibit-Lending Club” that is a summary of the entire account (name, address, apr, payment amount, etc) On the bottom of this it states that this form was created by Velocity in order to summarize events. My address is wrong and says “123 Street” which funny because the correct address is on some of the pages. Quote
LaneBlane Posted May 5 Report Posted May 5 During discovery my friend received a couple documents that were marked "Copy of Authoritative Document" across the page instead of just "Copy". When we researched what an Authoritative Document was, we discovered it is considered an original, electronic version that is a unique, tamper-proof, legally binding copy. These documents are "vaulted" and maintained in a secure electronic system. If you haven't received authoritative copies of your documents, you can request these during discovery. This is what the header/footer of the Authoritative Documents in my friend's case look like. The top shows the footer and the bottom line is the header. 3 hours ago, Mancuso_212 said: Also, there are four pages that show payments and breakdown and these pages don't have a created or copy date. Looks like they were just printed. My friend received something that sounds the same. Is it a spreadsheet of payments that anyone could have produced? 1 Quote
Mancuso_212 Posted May 5 Author Report Posted May 5 25 minutes ago, LaneBlane said: During discovery my friend received a couple documents that were marked "Copy of Authoritative Document" across the page instead of just "Copy". When we researched what an Authoritative Document was, we discovered it is considered an original, electronic version that is a unique, tamper-proof, legally binding copy. These documents are "vaulted" and maintained in a secure electronic system. If you haven't received authoritative copies of your documents, you can request these during discovery. This is what the header/footer of the Authoritative Documents in my friend's case look like. The top shows the footer and the bottom line is the header. My friend received something that sounds the same. Is it a spreadsheet of payments that anyone could have produced? Yes. Its a blank sheet with payment amount, interest, principle but its blank in the sense that there is no “loan id” or “cooy” like all the others. The other pages do say copy of authoritative document, same header / footer. Quote
LaneBlane Posted May 5 Report Posted May 5 You're striking out on many of the things I can think of that can potentially help you. You still have the Loan ID redactions and the variance in the Truth in Lending statement and the promissory note. There's also that incorrect address for you. Did you receive a Bill of Sale with other transfer of ownership documents that include a long list of owners? Does the amount that appears on the collection notices you received match the amount the documents say you owe? Did Velocity send the collection notices, or was it another company? When did you make your last payment on this account? On the Truth in Lending Disclosure Statement, do any of the amounts or percentages have an "(e)" next to it? On my friend's version of this document, it includes the following that says "(e) means estimate". If there is no (e), it should be a final version that should match the promissory note. Quote
Mancuso_212 Posted May 5 Author Report Posted May 5 7 hours ago, LaneBlane said: You're striking out on many of the things I can think of that can potentially help you. You still have the Loan ID redactions and the variance in the Truth in Lending statement and the promissory note. There's also that incorrect address for you. Did you receive a Bill of Sale with other transfer of ownership documents that include a long list of owners? Does the amount that appears on the collection notices you received match the amount the documents say you owe? Did Velocity send the collection notices, or was it another company? When did you make your last payment on this account? On the Truth in Lending Disclosure Statement, do any of the amounts or percentages have an "(e)" next to it? On my friend's version of this document, it includes the following that says "(e) means estimate". If there is no (e), it should be a final version that should match the promissory note. Yes. I did receive a bill of sale with many signatures. Basically states it bought a “lot”. Last payment was made Oct.2024. There is no “e” anywhere on the statement. Based on your knowledge and history with this, is arbitration still the best route to go ? If so, just request un-redacted documents and point everything out ? Quote
nobk4me Posted May 5 Report Posted May 5 I would still advocate arbitration, even if you don't have violations. It's your right under the contract. And the cost of arb is so high, to the JDB, that the cost alone is likely to make them go away. Is JAMS available in the contract? If so, choose JAMS, as they are much more expensive than AAA. Quote
Mancuso_212 Posted May 5 Author Report Posted May 5 2 hours ago, nobk4me said: I would still advocate arbitration, even if you don't have violations. It's your right under the contract. And the cost of arb is so high, to the JDB, that the cost alone is likely to make them go away. Is JAMS available in the contract? If so, choose JAMS, as they are much more expensive than AAA. Yes, JAMS is an option. This is a big debt. Not so sure they will give up easily. Quote
LaneBlane Posted May 6 Report Posted May 6 12 hours ago, Mancuso_212 said: Based on your knowledge and history with this, is arbitration still the best route to go ? If so, just request un-redacted documents and point everything out ? Arbitration is a good route to go, especially on a $14K debt. There are some material facts in dispute regarding the documentation, including redacted copies. If the other side attempted to argue you filed a frivolous complaint in arbitration, and seek reimbursement of their costs and attorney's fees, this would be your defense against that. Just so you know, my friend's LendingClub debt was just over $6K, and the JDB in that case followed her into arbitration by paying all their fees/costs. There were some significant document issues involved which eventually led to her prevailing. Your case is for $14K, so I doubt Velocity will simply walk away from this. Does the amount shown on the collection notices match the amount on the running balance statement? Are you in a position to make a settlement offer? Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.